Next Boyfriend

Modern Dating Culture · 9 min read

People once cited romcoms to describe the love they hoped for ...

Romantic dread expects disappointment. And modern dating lives somewhere in the uneasy space between the two. Dr Lisa Portolan is an academic and researcher ...

People once cited romcoms to describe the love they hoped for ... — Modern Dating Culture article on Next Boyfriend

Staff Writer · April 29, 2026

Our take

Remember when "meet-cutes" and grand gestures were the gold standard for romantic aspirations? Today, it feels like our collective dating narrative has shifted from hopeful rom-coms to a perpetual state of "romantic dread," a term perfectly coined by The Guardian. This isn't just about cynicism; it's a systemic anxiety perpetuated by endless swiping, ghosting, and the constant digital comparison trap. For women navigating this landscape, understanding this shift isn't just academic – it's crucial for protecting your heart and sanity while still daring to hope for the love you truly deserve.

Key takeaways

  • There was a time, not so long ago, when the blueprint for love was etched in the celluloid of romantic comedies.
  • Dr. Lisa Portolan, an academic and researcher cited in the Guardian piece, encapsulates this phenomenon perfectly: "Romantic dread expects disappointment." This isn't just about being jaded; it's a learned response to a…
  • The Guardian article mentions how "doomscrolling has replaced romcoms" as our primary cultural reference point for relationships.
  • For women, this romantic dread carries an extra layer of burden.

From Enchanted Evenings to Endless Swiping: The Rom-Com Recession

There was a time, not so long ago, when the blueprint for love was etched in the celluloid of romantic comedies. We envisioned ourselves as Meg Ryan, finding unexpected love in a bustling bookstore, or Julia Roberts, charming her way around London. These narratives, while often fantastical, offered a comforting promise: despite the odds, true love was out there, waiting to be discovered with a dash of serendipity and a sprinkle of grand gestures. The Guardian's recent article acutely observes this cultural shift, noting that "People once cited romcoms to describe the love they hoped for..." It’s a poignant reminder of a collective optimism that feels increasingly distant in our current dating landscape.

Today, that vibrant optimism has been largely overshadowed by a pervasive sense of "romantic dread." This isn't just a fleeting feeling; it's a deeply ingrained apprehension, a pre-emptive anxiety about the inevitable disappointments, heartbreaks, and frustrations that seem to define modern dating. The endless scroll of dating apps, the curated online personas, the pressure to constantly perform – these elements have coalesced to create an environment where hope often feels like a liability rather than a virtue.

The Rise of Romantic Dread: Why We Expect Disappointment

Dr. Lisa Portolan, an academic and researcher cited in the Guardian piece, encapsulates this phenomenon perfectly: "Romantic dread expects disappointment." This isn't just about being jaded; it's a learned response to a dating scene that often feels designed to chew up and spit out hopeful romantics. We've all heard the stories, or lived them ourselves: the promising first date that leads to ghosting, the "situationship" that never progresses, the constant feeling of being evaluated and discarded based on a few photos and a witty bio.

This dread isn't baseless. It's fueled by several factors:

  • Paradox of Choice: Dating apps offer an abundance of options, leading to analysis paralysis and the constant feeling that someone "better" is just a swipe away, making commitment feel less appealing.
  • Superficiality: The initial evaluation on apps is largely based on aesthetics and superficial details, often bypassing deeper connection until much later, if at all.
  • Lack of Accountability: The ease of disengaging (ghosting, soft-ghosting) without consequence fosters a culture of emotional detachment.
  • Social Media Comparison: Constantly seeing curated "perfect" relationships online can heighten feelings of inadequacy and dissatisfaction with our own dating experiences.

Doomscrolling for Love: The Digital Dilemma

The Guardian article mentions how "doomscrolling has replaced romcoms" as our primary cultural reference point for relationships. This analogy is chillingly accurate. Just as we endlessly scroll through negative news, we find ourselves in a similar loop with dating apps, perpetually seeking something better, fearing we'll miss out, and often encountering more negativity than genuine connection.

This digital immersion creates a constant background hum of anxiety. Every notification could be the one, or it could be another disappointment. We invest emotional energy in profiles and conversations that often lead nowhere, depleting our reserves and reinforcing the dread. It's a cycle that, if left unchecked, can leave us feeling emotionally exhausted and hyper-vigilant, making it even harder to embrace vulnerability when a genuine connection does arise.

The Invisible Labor of Modern Dating

For women, this romantic dread carries an extra layer of burden. We're often conditioned to be the emotional caretakers, the ones who nurture connections, and the ones who are more acutely aware of the ticking clock of societal expectations. The mental and emotional labor involved in navigating modern dating is immense:

  • Decoding Mixed Signals: Is he busy or just not interested? Is this a date or just "hanging out"?
  • Managing Expectations: Learning to temper enthusiasm to avoid crushing disappointment.
  • Emotional Resilience: Constantly rebounding from rejections and non-starters.
  • Safety Concerns: The added layer of vigilance required for personal safety when meeting strangers.

This invisible labor contributes significantly to the pervasive dread, making dating feel less like an exciting adventure and more like a demanding, often unrewarding, second job.

Reclaiming Hope: Practical Steps to Combat Dread

So, how do we navigate this "uneasy space" between rom-com idealism and romantic dread? The key isn't to swing to either extreme but to find a grounded, empowered middle path.

1. Define Your Non-Negotiables (and Your "Nice-to-Haves")

Before you even open a dating app or agree to another date, get crystal clear on what you absolutely need in a partner and a relationship. These are your foundational values, your deal-breakers.

  • Actionable Advice: Make a list. Be specific. Do you need someone emotionally available? Financially responsible? Aligned on family values? Also, distinguish these from "nice-to-haves" (e.g., loves hiking, tall, specific job). This clarity helps you filter effectively and prevents you from settling out of fear or loneliness.

2. Curate Your Digital Dating Experience

You control your online environment. Don't let the apps control you.

  • Actionable Advice:
    • Set Time Limits: Dedicate specific, limited time slots for swiping and messaging. Avoid endless scrolling.
    • Be Selective: Don't swipe right on everyone. Be discerning. Quality over quantity.
    • Take Breaks: If you're feeling overwhelmed or cynical, delete the apps for a week, a month, or longer. Use that time to focus on yourself and your existing relationships.
    • Unfollow Triggering Content: If certain social media accounts make you feel worse about your dating life, unfollow them.

3. Shift Your Mindset: From Outcome-Focused to Experience-Focused

Romantic dread thrives on anticipating negative outcomes. Try to reframe your approach to dating.

  • Actionable Advice: Instead of "Is this person 'the one'?", ask "Am I enjoying this conversation/date?" Focus on learning about yourself and others, practicing communication skills, and having interesting experiences. Every date doesn't have to lead to marriage; it can simply be an opportunity for connection and growth.

4. Build Your Inner Resilience Toolkit

Dating will inevitably involve setbacks. Your ability to bounce back is crucial.

  • Actionable Advice:
    • Strong Support System: Lean on friends and family who uplift you.
    • Self-Care Rituals: Prioritize activities that recharge you (hobbies, exercise, mindfulness).
    • Therapy/Coaching: If dread feels overwhelming, consider professional support to process emotions and develop coping strategies.
    • Journaling: Venting frustrations and reflecting on experiences can be incredibly cathartic.

The Power of the "Micro-Connection"

While rom-coms painted grand narratives, true connection often starts small. In a world of fleeting digital exchanges, valuing and recognizing these "micro-connections" can be a powerful antidote to dread.

  • Real-World Example: That genuine laugh you shared over a quirky anecdote on a first date. The thoughtful follow-up text that shows he was listening. The comfortable silence you share. These small moments are the building blocks of real intimacy, far more valuable than a perfectly staged "meet-cute."

Navigating Red Flags and Green Lights

Part of combating dread is developing a keen eye for both red flags and green lights. Romantic dread can make us hyper-vigilant for negatives, sometimes blinding us to genuine positives.

  • Actionable Advice:
    • Trust Your Gut: If something feels off, it probably is. Don't rationalize away uncomfortable feelings.
    • Identify Your Red Flags: What behaviors are absolute deal-breakers for you (e.g., dismissiveness, inconsistency, lack of respect)?
    • Recognize Green Lights: What makes you feel safe, valued, and genuinely seen? Don't dismiss kindness, consistency, and active listening as "boring" just because they lack dramatic flair. These are the hallmarks of a healthy partnership.

Dating as Self-Discovery

Perhaps the most empowering shift we can make is to view dating not as a quest for a partner, but as a journey of self-discovery.

  • Actionable Advice: Each interaction, successful or not, teaches you something. What do you truly value? What boundaries do you need to set? What kind of communication works for you? What makes you feel alive and joyful? The more you understand yourself, the better equipped you'll be to attract a partner who truly complements you, rather than just filling a void.

The New Rom-Com: Realism with a Dash of Hope

We might never return to the unbridled optimism of 90s rom-coms, and perhaps that's okay. A healthy dose of realism can protect us from unrealistic expectations. However, romantic dread doesn't have to be our default setting. We can embrace a new narrative – one where we are discerning, resilient, and unapologetically hopeful.

The modern love story might not involve a race to the airport or a flash mob proposal. It might involve:

  • Two busy individuals making time for each other despite demanding schedules.
  • Honest conversations about past hurts and future aspirations.
  • The courage to be vulnerable despite the risk of disappointment.
  • Two imperfect people choosing each other, day after day, through the mundane and the magnificent.

This isn't about ignoring the difficulties, but about empowering ourselves to navigate them. It's about understanding the landscape, protecting our peace, and still, bravely, daring to open our hearts. The love we hope for today isn't a fantasy; it's a connection built on mutual respect, authentic communication, and the quiet, persistent effort of two people choosing to build something real. And that, in its own way, is the most profound romance of all.

Questions about Modern Dating Culture

What is a situationship?

A romantic relationship with the intimacy of dating but no agreed definition, exclusivity, or trajectory. It is distinguished from casual dating by the fact that at least one person usually wants more but has not asked.

Why do people ghost?

Mostly conflict avoidance rather than malice. Ending things explicitly requires tolerating someone's disappointment; disappearing costs nothing when you have no shared social network. Frequency rises with the number of concurrent options.

How do you get clarity without seeming needy?

Ask once, directly, and early — a plain question about what someone is looking for is not a demand. Someone who reacts badly to a calm question about intent has answered it.

Keep reading

Comments

No comments yet.