Original · Modern Dating Culture
Are you in a situationship or a relationship?
If you cannot say what you are without a fight, you are not confused. You are in an arrangement that benefits from your confusion.
A relationship can be new and still be named. A situationship feels like a relationship in private and like nothing when you try to describe it to a friend. You are not bad at words; the arrangement is built so the words snag.
The fuzzy middle includes sex, advice, holidays spent almost together, and a flinch when you say boyfriend. Readiness for more is not a mood you perform; it is a willingness to be claimed and to claim someone. What that means for your future is practical; can you make a plan three weeks out? Can you tell your sister his name without a disclaimer; can you ask about other people and get a straight answer?
Fear of commitment is a story he may tell; sometimes it is true, and he is not ready for anyone. Sometimes it is true only with you, which is its own answer. What this does to a search for a partner is that it eats the months you would have used to meet someone who can say yes. Dating on purpose is simply not lying about your aim; if your aim is a relationship, an open-ended almost is not a stepping stone. It is a delay.
Try this test without announcing it as a test. Invite him to something that implies you are a pair: a friend's birthday, a trip that needs a ticket, a Sunday with your niece. Watch the speed of the answer; a partner-shaped person will have a preference. A situationship will have a fog; fog is an answer.
- You know his friends, or you are a secret. Secrets are not romance. They are management.
- You can say "we" and he does not correct you.
- Exclusivity has been said out loud, not implied by jealousy.
- Future plans exist on a calendar, not only in bed.
- When you are hurt, he repairs. He does not call you intense for noticing.
If you have the closeness and none of the agreements, you are allowed to want the agreements. Ask. If the ask makes you the villain in his story, you were never confused about his character. You were hoping the closeness would talk him into courage; closeness does not do that. A sentence does, and only if he is already almost ready; we would rather you hear a no on a Thursday than spend another season translating his maybes. A no is a door; a maybe is a hallway with the lights off.
Borrow a friend's eyes for one conversation. Describe the last month without adjectives like complicated; say how many plans were kept, whether you are a secret, and whether exclusivity has been said out loud. If your friend looks confused, you are not in a relationship with a shy man; you are in an arrangement that requires a translator. Translators get tired; you are allowed to retire.
We think the wish for a name is healthy; a name lets you tell the truth at work when someone asks what you did this weekend. It lets you stop performing casual so he does not feel trapped; if he needs you casual in order to stay close, he needs a service, not a partner. You can love him and decline the service; that decline is not a failure of femininity or patience. It is the moment you stop hoping a hallway will turn into a room.
We use a plain test, and we say it without a metaphor; are you allowed to want him in public.
A relationship can be new and still be nameable. You can tell your sister, make a plan that is not a secret, and ask who else he is seeing without being treated as dramatic. An arrangement that needs you confused is asking you to do the work of a partner while he keeps the freedom of a maybe. We are not romantic about that bargain, because women pay for it in months they do not get back. If he wants you, he can say so in a sentence and then live as if the sentence were true. If he cannot, you are allowed to love what was good and decline to live in the hallway. Hope is not a plan; a plan has a name, a day, and a person who does not flinch when you use it.
Sources
- The Rise of 'Situationships': Friendships, Benefits, and Fuzzy Lines — The New York Times. Our summary
- The 'Situationship' to Relationship Pipeline: How to Signal Readiness for More — Facebook. Our summary
- Navigating the 'Situationship' Spectrum: What It Means for Your Future — Gottman. Our summary
- The 'Situationship': Navigating Commitment-Phobia in Casual Dating — Healthline. Our summary
- The Rise of 'Situationships': Navigating the Grey Area of Modern Relationships — Psychologytoday. Our summary
- What Does It Really Mean to Date Intentionally? — Cosmopolitan. Our summary